How Do We Feel About AI Use in Therapy?

About a year ago, I wrote a blog post on what to talk about in a consultation call with a potential new therapist. Now, a year later, there is an important question that I feel compelled to add: "Do you use AI to assist with your notes?"

Why and how therapists use AI in their practices
It's no big secret that therapists are often burned out, and many feel pressure to take on larger and larger caseloads, especially in community mental health centers and group practices. Naturally, as a result, AI seems like a tool that could help therapists reduce their time spent on documentation and allow them spend more of their time actually seeing clients (the part of the job many therapists enjoy most).
Enter: AI Note Takers. Many practices are now offering AI note takers as a perk of working there. These note takers tend to work one of two ways: either therapists can type a general summary of the session, which AI then reformats into a clinical note, or the therapist uses a (hopefully HIPAA-compliant) AI recording platform to record the session (in-person or telehealth), which then automatically generates a note at the end of the session.
Additionally, one of the top Electronic Health Record (EHR) platforms, SimplePractice, recently launched Care Aide, which offers many services, including one called Session Sidekick, which pops up suggestions on the therapist's screen during telehealth calls.
The idea behind these tools is to help therapists save time, reduce the burden of paperwork, and provide them additional support in sessions. Sounds pretty good, right? Let's get into how it helps and how it hurts.
Pros and Cons of AI Use in Therapy
Potential benefits of a therapist using AI:
They may spend less time on documentation, which means they can see more clients per week and may be able to charge a lower rate as a result.
A lot of these AI note takers provide a session summary for you, the client, to have, which could be helpful (although keep in mind, AI is famous for getting things wrong).
Some of these tools could help therapists remember important things they wanted to bring up in session and could potentially help the therapist notice things they may not have thought of otherwise.
Potential downsides of a therapist using AI:
Because they're not writing up your notes, they aren't spending the additional time reflecting on your case, and therefore miss out on potentially valuable insights.
Because they're spending less time on documentation, they're likely seeing additional clients, which could prove to be more taxing than they anticipate. This has the potential to impact the quality of care you receive.
Privacy issues: While the built-in AI tools used by EHRs are marketed as HIPAA-compliant, there is still risk involved, especially if the entirety of your session is being recorded to generate the note. Additionally, if therapists are using other tools (such as ChatGPT or Claude), they may not be HIPAA-compliant to begin with.
The therapist's competency could suffer over time, as early research is showing that overuse of AI can impact critical thinking. Offloading important tasks related to the therapeutic process could reduce therapists' capacity for doing this work without the help of AI.
There is also the potential for AI tools to have a negative impact on the future of the counseling profession at large. Therapists are receiving offers of hundreds of thousands of dollars to provide their notes and session information to help train AI tools. It appears the intention is to help improve AI's capacity for performing empathy, which seems like the next step in working towards having AI replace therapists altogether.
In addition to all of this, there are the non-therapy-related downsides, such as the impact on the environment, racial and gender biases, and impact on the job market, especially for entry-level positions.
Why I don't use AI for notes or any other aspect of my clinical work
It seems like overnight, AI tools have become baked into all of the websites and tools we use every day. As I write this, on the lefthand side of my screen the first button on Wix's menu bar says "AI tools." AI summaries show up first on Google, AI chatbots are becoming harder to spot on customer service calls, and Meta is pushing their AI on all of their platforms.
So while it feels nearly impossible to forgo AI completely, bringing AI into my therapy work is a boundary I am committed to putting in place. I'll admit that there were times in the early days of AI where I used it to help with treatment plans and adapting notes for insurance companies (using general, de-identified information), but I have since decided that it's not worth the risks and downsides. I have also asked AI to adapt previous blog posts to optimize it for SEO (but not this one! I wouldn't be able to stand the irony). Is it possible I'll do that again in the future? Maybe. But it feels different to me to use it for my marketing work than to use it on my clinical work.
I don't blame my colleagues who have attempted to address their burnout by taking the burden of documentation off their plates, but I have decided that it would not align with my values.
To be honest, I like writing my therapy notes. It allows me to reflect on my sessions, discover new insights I didn't think of during session, and release the session from my brain and body by leaving it all on the (virtual) page. Yes, in theory, it would be nice to spend less time writing notes and more time seeing clients, but I also know that my brain and heart can only hold so many people's stories at once, so seeing more clients (even without the burden of documentation) wouldn't necessarily be sustainable for me.
Things to keep an eye out for
If you're looking for a new therapist and you want to know if they use AI in their practice, the best thing you can do is ask them about their AI use during your consult call with them. Additionally, read all of their practice consent documents carefully. Is there a document where you're agreeing to AI use? It may be called something like "Consent for Use of Artificial Intelligence (AI) Tools in Therapy Services" or "Consent for Use of AI Tools with De-Identified Transcript Retention," and there will likely be a document asking you to consent to record audio. Keep in mind, even if a therapist typically uses AI for their notes, you can ask them not to use it for yours and you can decline to sign the consent documents.
If you're already seeing a therapist, review the consent documents you signed when you started with them and look for AI consent documents. You can also ask your therapist directly if they use AI in their clinical work. If the answer is yes and you're uncomfortable with that, don't give up on them right away! Have an honest conversation about how you're feeling, and ask them if they would be willing to write notes for your sessions without the use of AI. They may surprise you!
If you want to work with a therapist who is committed to keeping AI out of therapy, reach out to schedule a free 15-minute consultation to see if we're a good fit for therapy!





Comments